In a recent conversation, former Van Halen bassist Michael Anthony opened up about the band’s search for a new vocalist following David Lee Roth’s departure in 1985. Surprisingly, one of the names that surfaced during this pivotal time was Patty Smyth, known for her work with the hard rock band Scandal.
Anthony recalled that Eddie Van Halen had considered Smyth as a potential replacement. The band was in a state of uncertainty after Roth left, prompting discussions about their future direction. Warner Brothers, the band’s label, even suggested a name change in hopes of reuniting with Roth down the line.
While Smyth was approached for the role, she ultimately declined due to personal circumstances, including her pregnancy and the band’s notorious partying lifestyle. In a previous interview, she confirmed that the discussions were serious but complicated by her own life choices at the time.
Anthony reflected on the band’s realization that bringing in a female vocalist might not align with their image or sound. He noted that they collectively understood that Smyth’s style wouldn’t quite fit the band’s dynamic. This led them to eventually recruit Sammy Hagar, who would go on to lead the band to significant commercial success.
Interestingly, Smyth wasn’t the only singer considered by Van Halen. Other notable names included Jimmy Barnes, Daryl Hall, Eric Martin, and Steve Perry, all of whom had their own reasons for not joining the iconic rock group. Ultimately, Hagar’s arrival marked a new chapter for Van Halen, leading to several successful albums and a lasting legacy.

